PANTHEON
ExploreBuild My Library
© 2026 Pantheon — an atlas of the ideas that shaped how we think.
person1990–present

David Schmidtz

Disciplines:
political philosophy
ethics
political philosophy/classical liberal theory

Summary

David Schmidtz is an American philosopher at the University of Arizona known for his pluralist account of justice and defense of market institutions.

Core Contribution

Schmidtz argues that justice is not a single principle but a plurality of principles — desert, reciprocity, need, and equality — each appropriate to different social contexts, offering a pluralist alternative to both Rawlsian egalitarianism and strict Nozickian entitlement theory.

Key Spikes & Highlights

  • Justice pluralism (no single principle — desert, need, equality — can handle all cases; justice requires knowing which principle fits which context)
  • Instrumental commons (common property is efficient when governed by community norms; tragedy occurs from mismanagement not commonality)
  • Personal project permission (it is morally permissible to give special weight to your own projects and relationships)
  • Market as discovery (markets are not just efficient allocators but discovery processes that reveal what people value)

Notable Works & Achievements

The Limits of Government

Rational Choice and Moral Agency

Person, Polis, Planet

A Brief History of Liberty

Elements of Justice

Historical Influences

Robert Nozick Friedrich Hayek Adam Smith

Intellectual Lineage

Classical liberalism Nozickian libertarianism Pragmatist ethics

Contemporaries & Peers

Jason Brennan Will Kymlicka Thomas Nagel Michael Sandel

Minds Influenced

No recorded minds influenced.

Intellectual Posterity

Pluralist justice theory

Discussing

David Schmidtz

Ask anything about David Schmidtz — their ideas, influences, contradictions, legacy.

Sign in to start a conversation.